Research Determines Sender ID Ineffective Against Spam
Despite a renewed and aggressive PR campaign by Microsoft, statistical analysis demonstrates that “Sender ID” is ineffective as an anti-spam solution.
Ann Arbor, Michigan (PRWEB) June 20, 2006 –- OnlyMyEmail, Inc. (www.OnlyMyEmail.com). Despite a renewed and aggressive PR campaign by Microsoft, statistical analysis demonstrates that “Sender ID” is ineffective as an anti-spam solution.
Research conducted by OnlyMyEmail, Inc. during the last 60 days clearly reveals that emails sent by a domain without a published SPF record are actually slightly less likely to be spam than those sent by domains that publish Sender ID information in their DNS records; opposite to the promoted value of Sender ID.
Further, emails that return a positive match for Sender ID (a “pass” result) are not significantly more likely to be legitimate emails than those without a published SPF record; again contrary to the perceived benefits of implementing Sender ID.
Finally, if Sender ID were relied upon for the blocking emails, (based on a SPF result of “fail”) this would result in a false-positive rate of nearly 8.6%.
Combined, these results qualify Sender ID as being one of the most ineffective and least accurate anti-spam tools available anywhere, producing results no better than first-generation anti-spam filters now a decade out of date.
– Sender ID Analysis Results:
The data amassed during the last months reveal the spam-probability of emails based on SPF results:
SPF Fail 0.914 Sender fails to match SenderID
Softfail 0.885 IP addresses not specified
- - - - 0.500 Spam/Not-Spam midpoint
None 0.495 SenderID not published
SPF Pass 0.174 Positive Sender ID match
Translated into real-world terms the implications are both surprising and of significant importance to all email administrators:
* An email that fails Sender ID verification only has a 91.4% chance of actually being spam. If relied upon to accept or reject an email, 8.6% of emails rejected would be “false-positives” – causing a great deal of legitimate email to be blocked.
* On the other end of the spectrum, 1 out of 6 emails that “pass” Sender ID verification will actually be spam.
* The spam probability of an incoming email from a domain that does not publish Microsoft’s Sender ID data is almost a coin-flip, at 49.5% just slightly favoring the probability that it is actually not spam.
* This means that non-compliant domains are actually less likely to be sending spam than those networks who do publish SPF records within their DNS, though by an insignificant measure.
* Because the spam probability for emails sent by servers without SPF records is only 49.5% but rockets to 88.5% for those that return “softfail’ results, administrators who publish Sender ID/SPF records that are not specific regarding their sending IP addresses are increasing the likelihood that their outbound email will not be delivered by almost 79%.
These results translate into exceptionally bad news for email administrators who are actively relying on Sender ID in order to make decisions on whether or not to accept or reject inbound emails as even older “first-generation” spam filters were considerably more accurate than Sender ID is today.
Further, it’s clear that publishing SPF records for domains you manage could be disastrous to your outbound deliveries, unless you are specific regarding permitted sending IP addresses for your domains.
– Why Sender ID Failed
In what is very much a Judo-like technique, spammers now commonly publish SPF entries for their sending domains. In effect, spammers are using Sender ID as a weapon to increase spam delivery rates, made effective because of email administrator’s over-reliance on Sender ID.
For the spammer, the only shortcoming of publishing Sender ID information is that the spammer will have to abandon the domain within a few days as filters begin to correctly identify their sending domain as being one used for distributing spam.
This limitation is easily overcome by spammers who register thousands of “throw-away” domains for less than $10 a piece at Godaddy.com (where we observe that a great deal of these Sender ID compliant spam domains have been registered) and then aggressively rotate through these domains, discarding any domains whose rejection rate becomes too high.
Additionally, those spammers who rely on the use of infected and compromised personal computers and internet servers to send their spam messages won’t typically have any difficulties in passing SPF checks as those machines are quite often sending from their own network without any deception of the sending domain.
On the other hand, the problem of exceptionally high false-positives is exacerbated by two main factors:
* First and foremost, end-users do not understand Sender ID and will commonly have their email software configured to claim to be sending from their work or home addresses, even when they are not actually connected to those networks, causing their perfectly legitimate email to fail an SPF check.
* Additionally, many email administrators publish inaccurate SPF records without taking all possible legitimate sending servers (including business partners) for their domain into consideration; or they fail to update their domain’s Sender ID information when new servers or locations are added to their systems.
As a recent example, a mass mailing sent on the behalf of Network World failed SPF checking because the sending server was actually one belonging to a third-party business partner (mBlast.com) and their servers were not included in Network World’s published SPF records.
While these obstacles can be overcome in theory, doing so would require a vast amount of effort and expense, and substantially more end-user diligence than can be expected given the number of users who are still infected by obvious viruses, fall for internet get-rich-quick cons, and are too often duped by countless Phishing fraud emails.
How Sender ID Could Work
Sender ID has two Achilles’ heels that will continue to prevent this standard from being effective as an anti-spam solution.
First, because complying with Sender ID is not required, checking a sender’s SPF record does not provide the type of consistent data necessary in order to be reliable. As a pre-requisite to being effective, the Sender ID standard would need to be mandatory.
However, making Sender ID compulsory is not necessarily
desirable for the Internet, and is unlikely to occur given that it would require vast agreement throughout the world; would require substantial capital investments and would also cause disruptive change to the way many users and networks currently send email.
Secondly, because there is no cost or fee associated with publishing Sender ID information, spammers can obviously afford to send email that is fully SPF compliant, and many already do so today. In addition to requiring mandatory compliance, Microsoft, (who maintains patent rights to Sender ID and has existing licensing requirements) or some other entity, would need to establish a fee that is high enough to be prohibitive to the spammer’s business model.
While an annual Sender ID registration fee of perhaps as little as $100 per domain might be sufficient in this regard, it would have significant consequences.
Such a fee structure would no doubt drive a great number of domains off the Internet as many personal, family, hobby and activist related sites would be lost; and a great part of what makes the Internet so valuable to so many would cease to exist
Further, such pricing could create the potential for monopolistic domain registration practices. For example, if a dominant technology company were in a position to bundle free domain name…
June 15th, 2010 at 3:25 pm
Привет!! < a href=”http://onlylcd.ru/registration.aspx/ carlos@onlylcd.ru” >…< /a >
С уважением,
July 17th, 2011 at 4:05 pm
< b >< a href=”http://www.trustedpillspot.com/?ml=buy-generic-LEVITRA buy@generic.LEVITRA” >…< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Need cheap generic LEVITRA?
July 29th, 2011 at 9:55 am
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/coral_calcium3028/biography/?ml=Get-Coral-Calcium-Online Get@Coral.Calcium.Online” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buygeneric drugs
July 29th, 2011 at 11:34 am
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/abana549/biography/?ml=Order-Abana-Online Order@Abana.Online” >…< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buywithout prescription
July 30th, 2011 at 4:02 am
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/abilify655/biography/?ml=Abilify-5mg-10mg-15mg-20mg-30mg-Without-Prescription Abilify@5mg.10mg.15mg.20mg.30mg.Without.Prescription” >…< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buywithout prescription
July 30th, 2011 at 11:07 am
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/acai5431/biography/?ml=Buy-Discount-Acai Buy@Discount.Acai” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buynow it
July 31st, 2011 at 5:24 am
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/acai7030/biography/?ml=Buy-Generic-Acai-Without-Prescription Buy@Generic.Acai.Without.Prescription” >…< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buygeneric drugs
July 31st, 2011 at 4:57 pm
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/acai1961/biography/?ml=Cheap-Generic-Acai-500mg Cheap@Generic.Acai.500mg” >…< /a >
Buywithout prescription
August 1st, 2011 at 1:33 pm
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/abana4140/biography/?ml=Cheap-Abana-Online Cheap@Abana.Online” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buyno prescription
August 1st, 2011 at 9:31 pm
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/abilify7674/biography/?ml=Purchase-Generic-Abilify Purchase@Generic.Abilify” >.< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buynow it
August 2nd, 2011 at 6:41 pm
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/abana5984/biography/?ml=Get-Abana-Online Get@Abana.Online” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buyit now
August 3rd, 2011 at 5:11 am
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/abilify8175/biography/?ml=Order-Abilify-Online Order@Abilify.Online” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buygeneric pills
August 3rd, 2011 at 5:41 am
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/abilify3915/biography/?ml=Order-Cheap-Abilify Order@Cheap.Abilify” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buyno prescription
August 3rd, 2011 at 3:31 pm
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/abilify9488/biography/?ml=Buy-Generic-Abilify-5mg-10mg-15mg-20mg-30mg Buy@Generic.Abilify.5mg.10mg.15mg.20mg.30mg” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buygeneric meds
August 3rd, 2011 at 4:49 pm
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/abilify6414/biography/?ml=Cheap-Generic-Abilify-5mg-10mg-15mg-20mg-30mg Cheap@Generic.Abilify.5mg.10mg.15mg.20mg.30mg” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buyit now
August 3rd, 2011 at 6:47 pm
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/acai9942/biography/?ml=Buy-Acai-Online Buy@Acai.Online” >.< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buywithout prescription
August 4th, 2011 at 12:48 am
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/acai5876/biography/?ml=Order-Cheap-Acai Order@Cheap.Acai” >…< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buyit now
August 4th, 2011 at 2:46 am
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/acai3793/biography/?ml=Order-Discount-Acai Order@Discount.Acai” >…< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buyit now
August 4th, 2011 at 9:24 pm
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/acai4501/biography/?ml=Order-Generic-Acai Order@Generic.Acai” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buydrugs without prescription
August 5th, 2011 at 2:41 am
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/acai6985/biography/?ml=Cheap-Generic-Acai Cheap@Generic.Acai” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buyit now
August 5th, 2011 at 5:27 pm
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/accupril7182/biography/?ml=1 Buy@Accupril.Online” >.< /a >
Buygeneric meds
August 6th, 2011 at 11:31 pm
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/accutane5811/biography/?ml=1 Purchase@Accutane.Without.Prescription” >.< /a >
Buygeneric drugs
August 8th, 2011 at 8:11 pm
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/aciphex8153/biography/?ml=1 Buy@Generic.Aciphex.20mg” >.< /a >
Buynow it
August 9th, 2011 at 4:12 pm
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/acomplia740/biography/?ml=1 acomplia@diet.pills” >.< /a >
Buygeneric drugs
August 10th, 2011 at 11:36 pm
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/actonel46/biography/?ml=Buy-Actonel-35mg Buy@Actonel.35mg” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buygeneric drugs lzt
August 11th, 2011 at 9:04 am
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/actos6619/biography/?ml=Buy-Actos-Online Buy@Actos.Online” >.< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buygeneric drugs zfk
August 11th, 2011 at 7:29 pm
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/actos1846/biography/?ml=Buy-Generic-Actos-Without-Prescription Buy@Generic.Actos.Without.Prescription” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buygeneric drugs krg
August 12th, 2011 at 6:23 pm
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/adalat4685/biography/?ml=Order-Adalat-Online Order@Adalat.Online” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buygeneric meds qhr
August 12th, 2011 at 8:59 pm
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/adalat35/biography/?ml=Purchase-Discount-Adalat Purchase@Discount.Adalat” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buygeneric drugs krg
August 12th, 2011 at 10:02 pm
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/adalat202/biography/?ml=Get-Adalat-Online Get@Adalat.Online” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buygeneric meds qmo
August 13th, 2011 at 2:18 am
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/coral_calcium868/biography/?ml=Purchase-Coral-Calcium-Online Purchase@Coral.Calcium.Online” >.< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buyno prescription luw
August 14th, 2011 at 2:10 am
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/abilify6414/biography/?ml=Cheap-Generic-Abilify-5mg-10mg-15mg-20mg-30mg Cheap@Generic.Abilify.5mg.10mg.15mg.20mg.30mg” >.< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buywithout prescription yyn
August 14th, 2011 at 5:44 am
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/acai9942/biography/?ml=Buy-Acai-Online Buy@Acai.Online” >…< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buydrugs without prescription vrg
August 15th, 2011 at 4:10 pm
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/energy_boost8566/biography/?ml=Order-Energy-Boost-Online Order@Energy.Boost.Online” >.< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buygeneric drugs axm
August 15th, 2011 at 9:46 pm
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/energy_boost7603/biography/?ml=Purchase-Discount-Energy-Boost Purchase@Discount.Energy.Boost” >…< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buydrugs without prescription vrg
August 15th, 2011 at 10:45 pm
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/energy_boost8321/biography/?ml=Cheap-Energy-Boost-Online Cheap@Energy.Boost.Online” >…< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buydrugs without prescription jlg
August 15th, 2011 at 11:52 pm
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/energy_boost3769/biography/?ml=Get-Energy-Boost-Online Get@Energy.Boost.Online” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buyno prescription jui
August 18th, 2011 at 12:14 am
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/accutane410/biography/?ml=Buy-Generic-Accutane-10mg-20mg Buy@Generic.Accutane.10mg.20mg” >…< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buydrugs without prescription jlg
August 19th, 2011 at 7:42 am
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/aciphex2481/biography/?ml=Buy-Aciphex-20mg Buy@Aciphex.20mg” >.< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buygeneric drugs mby
August 19th, 2011 at 10:12 am
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/aciphex3902/biography/?ml=Purchase-Generic-Aciphex-20mg Purchase@Generic.Aciphex.20mg” >…< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buywithout prescription ccw
August 23rd, 2011 at 5:52 am
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/advair6239/biography/?ml=Order-Cheap-Advair Order@Cheap.Advair” >…< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buygeneric drugs vbr
August 23rd, 2011 at 11:14 pm
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/advair7733/biography/?ml=Order-Generic-Advair Order@Generic.Advair” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buydrugs without prescription hak
August 25th, 2011 at 11:58 am
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/albenza6862/biography/?ml=Buy-Albenza-Online Buy@Albenza.Online” >.< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buyit now ojb
August 25th, 2011 at 1:16 pm
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/albenza9046/biography/?ml=Buy-Cheap-Albenza Buy@Cheap.Albenza” >.< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buyit now ojb
August 25th, 2011 at 3:57 pm
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/albenza2194/biography/?ml=Order-Albenza-Online Order@Albenza.Online” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buydrugs without prescription faj
August 26th, 2011 at 2:37 am
< b >< a href=”http://trig.com/aldactone1747/biography/?ml=Buy-Aldactone-Online Buy@Aldactone.Online” >.< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buygeneric drugs hwi
August 27th, 2011 at 5:00 pm
< b >< a href=”http://www.box.net/view_shared/3oqrm8irvf?ml=id aloe@vera.juice.benefits.best” >.< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buygeneric meds
October 17th, 2011 at 4:10 am
< b >< a href=”http://community.landesk.com/support/bookmarks/3438?decorator=print#comments” >hiv research being conducted in usa< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buy_generic pills
October 19th, 2011 at 2:39 am
< b >< a href=”http://community.music123.com/bookmarks/1143?decorator=print#comments” >advair and contraindications< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buy_generic meds
October 19th, 2011 at 4:19 am
< b >< a href=”http://community.jboss.org/bookmarks/1477?decorator=print#comments” >canine heat cycles< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buy_without prescription
October 20th, 2011 at 6:40 am
< b >< a href=”http://www.protocolexchange.com/bookmarks/1211?decorator=print#comments” >apo amitriptyline< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buy_generic pills
October 21st, 2011 at 2:51 pm
< b >< a href=”http://solid.community.appliedbiosystems.com/bookmarks/1338?decorator=print#comments” >conquer online hacking tools< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buy_generic drugs
October 21st, 2011 at 7:51 pm
< b >< a href=”http://www.screwfix.com/community/bookmarks/1540?decorator=print#comments” >symptoms of prescription drug abuse< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buy_drugs without prescription
October 26th, 2011 at 9:31 pm
< b >< a href=”http://www.harmonycentral.com/bookmarks/6202?decorator=print#comments” >working and twin pregnancy< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buy_now it
October 29th, 2011 at 7:08 am
< b >< a href=”http://www.screwfix.com/community/bookmarks/1923?decorator=print#comments” >singapore secure psychiatric forensic unit< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buy_no prescription
October 29th, 2011 at 5:05 pm
< b >< a href=”http://talk.sonyericsson.com/bookmarks/2055?decorator=print#comments” >mini insulin fridge< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buy_generic drugs
October 30th, 2011 at 4:44 am
< b >< a href=”http://eltcommunity.com/elt/bookmarks/3083?decorator=print#comments” >cheap fetal heart rate monitor< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buy_generic meds
October 30th, 2011 at 12:12 pm
< b >< a href=”http://cellnetwork.community.invitrogen.com/bookmarks/3160?decorator=print#comments” >avelox treats for bacteria< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buy_drugs without prescription
October 30th, 2011 at 6:48 pm
< b >< a href=”http://policy2.org/bookmarks/3581?decorator=print#comments” >drug treatment for bipolar disorder< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buy_generic pills
November 5th, 2011 at 7:55 pm
< b >< a href=”http://beta.hopestreetgroup.org/bookmarks/4790?decorator=print#comments” >build muscle mass diet< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buy_drugs without prescription
November 10th, 2011 at 2:09 pm
< b >< a href=”http://beta.hopestreetgroup.org/bookmarks/5671?decorator=print#comments” >hiv quality of life survey tools< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buy_drugs without prescription
November 10th, 2011 at 7:09 pm
< b >< a href=”http://community.techweb.com/bookmarks/3589?decorator=print#comments” >obesity in moorhead minnesota< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buy_now
November 12th, 2011 at 5:48 pm
< b >< a href=”http://solid.community.appliedbiosystems.com/bookmarks/2628?decorator=print#comments” >breast cancer site is having trouble< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buy_drugs without prescription
November 15th, 2011 at 5:46 pm
< b >< a href=”http://cellnetwork.community.invitrogen.com/bookmarks/2823?decorator=print#comments” >boost metabolism foods< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buy_now
November 16th, 2011 at 10:06 pm
< b >< a href=”http://solid.community.appliedbiosystems.com/bookmarks/2823?decorator=print#comments” >substitute for diovan hct< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Buy_now
December 10th, 2011 at 11:01 pm
< b >< a href=”http://downloadrockalternative.info?author=all Download@alternative.Rock” >.< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >
Search rock UK Charts